Skip to main content

Table 4 Decoupling effect of carbon footprint and economic growth in Wuhan from 2001 to 2020

From: Decoupling effect and driving factors of carbon footprint in megacity Wuhan, Central China

Year

Total carbon footprint

Energy consumption account

Industrial production process account

Pollution emission account

Livestock account

αn

State

αn

State

αn

State

αn

State

αn

State

2001–2002

0.97

Expansion connection

1.04

Expansion connection

0.79

Weak decoupling

0.13

Weak decoupling

1.54

Expansion negative decoupling

2002–2003

1.41

Expansion negative decoupling

1.45

Expansion negative decoupling

0.19

Weak decoupling

1.85

Expansion negative decoupling

0.29

Weak decoupling

2003–2004

1.84

Expansion negative decoupling

1.92

Expansion negative decoupling

1.27

Expansion negative decoupling

1.37

Expansion negative decoupling

0.18

Weak decoupling

2004–2005

0.68

Weak decoupling

0.71

Weak decoupling

1.36

Expansion negative decoupling

0.02

Weak decoupling

0.22

Weak decoupling

2005–2006

0.45

Weak decoupling

0.56

Weak decoupling

0.65

Weak decoupling

− 1.2

Strong decoupling

− 0.01

Strong decoupling

2006–2007

− 0.34

Strong decoupling

− 0.43

Strong decoupling

0.96

Expansion connection

0.07

Weak decoupling

− 0.07

Strong decoupling

2007–2008

0.05

Weak decoupling

− 0.01

Strong decoupling

1.37

Expansion negative decoupling

− 0.29

Strong decoupling

0.17

Weak decoupling

2008–2009

− 0.34

Strong decoupling

− 0.45

Strong decoupling

− 0.11

Strong decoupling

1.38

Expansion negative decoupling

− 0.53

Strong decoupling

2009–2010

0.73

Weak decoupling

0.89

Expansion connection

0.53

Weak decoupling

− 1.35

Strong decoupling

0.07

Weak decoupling

2010–2011

0.32

Weak decoupling

0.33

Weak decoupling

0.02

Weak decoupling

0.79

Weak decoupling

− 0.01

Strong decoupling

2011–2012

− 0.41

Strong decoupling

− 0.5

Strong decoupling

0.14

Weak decoupling

0.24

Weak decoupling

0.81

Expansion connection

2012–2013

1.04

Expansion connection

1.16

Expansion connection

0.76

Weak decoupling

− 0.48

Strong decoupling

− 0.18

Strong decoupling

2013–2014

0.26

Weak decoupling

0.11

Weak decoupling

0.48

Weak decoupling

3.06

Expansion negative decoupling

0.09

Weak decoupling

2014–2015

− 0.68

Strong decoupling

− 0.68

Strong decoupling

− 0.22

Strong decoupling

− 1.07

Strong decoupling

− 2.33

Strong decoupling

2015–2016

− 0.61

Strong decoupling

− 0.63

Strong decoupling

− 0.54

Strong decoupling

0.2

Weak decoupling

− 5.21

Strong decoupling

2016–2017

0.43

Weak decoupling

0.47

Weak decoupling

− 0.26

Strong decoupling

0.71

Weak decoupling

− 0.33

Strong decoupling

2017–2018

0.2

Weak decoupling

0.23

Weak decoupling

− 0.01

Strong decoupling

0.16

Weak decoupling

− 0.23

Strong decoupling

2018–2019

0.37

Weak decoupling

0.37

Weak decoupling

− 0.19

Strong decoupling

1.22

Expansion negative decoupling

− 2.81

Strong decoupling

2019–2020

4.7

Decay decoupling

4.97

Decay decoupling

3.5

Decay decoupling

2.56

Decay decoupling

− 3.43

Strong negative decoupling