Skip to main content

Table 2 Results of two-way ANOVA to test the effects of N addition (N) and drought (D) on WUEINST, NUEINST, WUELT and NUELT for the six studied species

From: Effects of nitrogen addition and drought on the relationship between nitrogen- and water-use efficiency in a temperate grassland

Functional groups

Species

Factors

df

WUEINST

NUEINST

WUELT

NUELT

F

p

F

p

F

p

F

p

Grass

L. chinensis

N

1

1.13

0.307

4.12

0.063

0.22

0.645

38.48

< 0.001

D

1

3.95

0.068

2.9

0.113

51.94

< 0.001

27.86

< 0.001

N × D

1

2.08

0.172

3.63

0.079

5.57

0.032

8.78

0.010

S. baicalensis

N

1

0.59

0.367

3.20

0.103

8.05

0.013

115.54

< 0.001

D

1

2.37

0.145

47.28

< 0.001

24.60

< 0.001

197.66

< 0.001

N × D

1

0.03

0.856

0.99

0.342

15.85

< 0.001

38.52

< 0.001

Leguminous forb

T. lanceolata

N

1

1.45

0.250

19.85

0.002

3.54

0.083

7.84

0.013

D

1

0.01

0.938

27.84

< 0.001

47.52

< 0.001

3.84

0.068

N × D

1

0.41

0.533

13.53

0.006

0.53

0.526

0.73

0.406

Non-leguminous forb

P. bifurca

N

1

1.17

0.305

0.10

0.755

17.43

< 0.001

24.89

< 0.001

D

1

1.82

0.207

9.43

0.011

83.49

 < 0.001

23.54

 < 0.001

N × D

1

0.46

0.513

3.88

0.074

0.19

0.671

10.09

0.006

T. squarrosum

N

1

0.01

0.911

5.19

0.049

1.61

0.229

9.58

0.009

D

1

1.15

0.312

5.33

0.046

57.07

< 0.001

12.95

0.004

N × D

1

0.10

0.755

1.52

0.248

0.02

0.893

5.99

0.031

K. centauroide

N

1

0.27

0.614

3.64

0.079

1.44

0.250

114.06

< 0.001

D

1

2.35

0.149

4.76

0.048

37.64

< 0.001

1.61

0.221

N × D

1

0.03

0.862

0.45

0.514

0.84

0.375

1.02

0.327

  1. Model: lmer (RUE ~ N addition × Drought + 1| Block)
  2. df degrees of freedom
  3. Significant p values (< 0.05) are bolded