Spatial variation of the influence of distance from surface water on riparian plant communities in the Okavango Delta, Botswana

Abstract

Introduction

Understanding the environmental factors that influence riparian vegetation community composition and distribution is important for understanding wetland ecosystem functioning. This understanding can further serve to inform policy aimed at conserving wetlands such as the Okavango Delta. In the Okavango Delta, information on the influence of distance from surface water on vegetation community composition and structure is limited. The objective of this study was to determine the relationship between distance from surface water and riparian plant communities at different sites in the Okavango Delta.

Methods

Vegetation sampling was conducted in four sites in 20 m × 10 m belted plots placed perpendicular to the river bank at 0–10 m, 10–20 m, 20–30 m, 30–40 m, and 40–50 m distance classes. At each site, 10–15 plots were sampled at each distance class. Basal area, species richness, cover, and plant diversity were determined for each plot. Indicator species analysis was used to determine the characteristic species at each distance class. One-way analysis of variance and Tukey post hoc analyses were used to compare species diversity, richness, cover, and basal area between distance classes. Generalized linear mixed (GLM) model was used to test for the overall impact of site and distance on each plant parameter.

Results

Mean species richness was significantly (p < 0.05) higher at 0–10 m than at 20–30 m, 30–40 m, and 40–50 m in Boro. There was no significant difference within other sites. Mean species diversity also varied significantly (p < 0.05) in Boro where it was higher at 0–10 m and 10–20 m than at 30–40 m. Mean basal area differed significantly within Jao and Upper Panhandle. In Jao, it was higher (p < 0.05) at 0–10 m than at other distance classes. Mean percentage canopy cover differed significantly within all sites. In addition to this, plant species composition also changed along distance from surface water within each site. From GLM analysis, both distance and site significantly (p < 0.05) influenced diversity and basal area. Species richness and cover were significantly (p < 0.05) influenced by site only.

Conclusion

Distance from surface water and site are important determinants of riparian plant dynamics in the Okavango Delta.

Introduction

Riparian plant communities, found along river banks, are transition zones between terrestrial and aquatic systems (Naiman and Décamps 1997). In semi-arid environments, riparian plant communities are commonly dynamic showing high habitat heterogeneity and diverse ecological processes and are often rich in plant species diversity (Naiman et al. 2005). The distribution of riparian plant communities is controlled by soil redox conditions, flooding regime, soil chemistry, and light intensity (Everson and Boucher 1998). Surface water availability and fluvial disturbance are also environmental factors that influence plant species composition and distribution along lateral gradients in riparian habitats (Malanson 1993). Flooding disturbance on riparian vegetation decreases with increasing distance from surface water due to an increase of depth to groundwater in the riparian zone (Lite et al. 2005).

Depth to groundwater influences the distribution of plant species, density, and size structure in riparian zones because it determines the availability of a permanent surface water source (Stromberg and Richter 1996). Decline in groundwater may result in a reduction in plant species abundance, cover, productivity, and cause death (Stromberg et al. 2007) while a shallow groundwater table can support high plant species density (Naumburg et al. 2005). Depth to groundwater has been found to increase with increasing distance from surface water in the San Pedro River in the USA (Lite et al. 2005). This has also been found to be the case in the Okavango Delta (McCarthy 2006). Excess water may lead to anoxic conditions in the root zone resulting in stress to tree species due to reduced respiration (Drew 1997). In riparian ecosystems, plant sites close to surface water mostly experience anoxia because of low depth to groundwater resulting in water submerging the roots (Capon 2005). In habitats experiencing high evapotranspiration rates, rainwater may leach salts that accumulate in the soil surface into the groundwater table. If the groundwater table is shallow, the root zone may then be exposed to a saline water layer leading to a reduction in plant growth (Naumburg et al. 2005) due to the harmful effects of salts and anoxic conditions. Conversely, in areas with relatively shallow groundwater (i.e., where plants are using it as a source of water), declining groundwater depth can lead to a reduction in plant species richness and total cover due to a decrease in the availability of a permanent water source to promote primary production (Stromberg and Richter 1996).

Studies in other riparian wetland ecosystems (e.g., Stromberg and Richter 1996; Shafroth et al. 2000; Lite et al. 2005; Stromberg et al. 2007) have shown that distance from surface water through its influence on depth to groundwater is an important environmental variable that influences the distribution and composition of riparian plant communities. In the San Pedro River (USA) riparian plant species tolerant of wet rooting conditions and low depth to groundwater were dominant at sites closer to surface water (ca. 3 m) while those that prefer dry conditions and are adapted to greater depth to groundwater were dominant in more elevated sites (ca. 4–8 m) which were found further away from surface water (Stromberg and Richter 1996). An increase in depth to groundwater may lead to a reduction in abundance of riparian woodland species (Shafroth et al. 2000; Baird et al. 2005). However, some riparian plant species have developed morphological adaptations to cope with dry conditions imposed by increased depth to groundwater (Shafroth et al. 2000). These adaptations include tap roots which help them to reach for deep groundwater (Ellery et al. 1993). Due to different tolerance levels, riparian plant species are found in different microsites in the riparian zone. Plant species that are tolerant of shallow depth to groundwater inhabit regularly saturated sites while those that prefer deep depth to groundwater occupy occasionally flooded sites (Damasceno-Junior et al. 2005).

In the Okavango Delta, information on the influence of surface water on riparian plant communities is generally limited. The study by Ellery et al. (1993) found a strong correlation between depth to groundwater and woody plant species distribution in the Okavango Delta, and changes in plant species composition were positively correlated with depth to groundwater and elevation above open water. It was generally found that Diospyros mespiliformis Hochst. EX A.D.C, Garcinia livingstonei T. Anderson, Croton megalobotrys Müll. Arg, and Senegalia nigrescens (Acacia nigrescens Oliv) preferred relatively shallow depth to groundwater while Vachellia erioloba (Acacia erioloba), V. tortilis (A. tortilis (Forssk) Hayne), Senegalia mellifera (A. mellifera (Vahl) Benth), and Colophospermum mopane (J. Kirk ex Benth) J. Kirk ex J. Léonard were able to establish and grow where the water depth was greater. However, the study was limited in terms of geographical coverage as it only covered a single island. That study also did not investigate the effect of distance from surface water on riparian plant species composition and distribution.

The recent study by Tsheboeng et al. (2017) investigated the influence of distance from surface water on riparian plant species composition and distribution in the Okavango Delta. However, that study was limited as it did not study response of plant species to distance from surface water in different sites. The aim of the current study was to determine the response of riparian plant communities to distance from surface water in different sites in the Okavango Delta. The Okavango Delta was chosen for this study because it experiences minimum anthropogenic impacts on its water and vegetation resources. As a result, it provides a good case study to investigate the influence of distance from surface water on riparian woodland vegetation. It was hypothesized that species richness, diversity, tree height, basal stem area, species richness, and canopy cover will vary with changing distance from surface water in all the sites in the Okavango Delta.

Methods

Study areas

The study was conducted in the Okavango Delta. The selected study sites were Boro, Jao, Upper Panhandle (UPH), and Seronga (Fig. 1; Table 1).

Fig. 1

Sampling sites in the Okavango Delta

Table 1 Characterization of different sampling sites in the Okavango Delta

The hydrology of the Okavango Delta is characterized by annual flood pulses originating from the Angolan highlands, the peak flows of which generally pass the Mohembo inlet region between March and April, reaching the distal region between May and October (McCarthy 2006). The flood extent in the Delta shows intra- and inter-annual variations (Wolski et al. 2006). The Okavango Delta inflows (flooding) also vary pluri-annually in which there are sequences of years with higher or lower inflows than average (Mazvimavi and Wolski 2006). The Okavango Delta receives mean annual rainfall (between November and February) of approximately 550 mm (Wilson and Dincer 1976). In the Okavango Delta, groundwater depth varies with distance from surface water such that it is higher and lower in sites closer to and further away from the permanent swamps respectively (McCarthy 2006).

Common woodland species include Vachellia erioloba E. Meyer, Senegalia nigrescens, Croton megalobotrys, Phoenix reclinata Jacq, Diospyros mespiliformis, and Garcinia livingstonei. The soil in the riparian zone is fine sand (Ringrose et al. 2007) resulting in high permeability. The soil salinity in the Okavango Delta is influenced by flooding and transpiration by riparian vegetation (McCarthy and Ellery 1994). During flood peak, the salinity reduces and it increases when water levels are low. This is because the flood waters may dilute the salts (Tsheboeng et al. 2014). Salinity is also high in low flooding frequency floodplains and low in high flooding frequency regions (Bonyongo and Mubyana 2004).

Vegetation sampling

Four sites were selected for sampling. Riparian woody vegetation was sampled between February 2012 and November 2013. Riparian woody vegetation was sampled in 10 m × 20 m plots placed perpendicular to the surface water-dry land boundary covering a 50-m distance at 0–10 m, 10–20 m, 20–30 m, 30–40 m, and 40-50 m intervals. The distance was measured from the current high water line. In each plot, all woody plant species were identified, estimates of canopy cover made following the method by Braun-Blanquet (Ellenberg and Mueller-Dombois 1974), and tree height and stem size measured for each plant species. Stem circumference was measured using a measuring tape at breast height (1.3 m) while woody plant height was visually estimated. Plant species diversity, richness, basal area, and density were calculated for each distance class. At each site, 75 plots were sampled resulting in a total of 300 plots sampled for the whole study area.

Statistical analysis

Change in woodland species composition in different sites was determined at each distance class based on indicator species analysis (McCune and Grace 2000). Indicator species were determined from mean percentage cover/abundance and relative frequency at each distance class. It was calculated as

$$ \mathrm{Indicator}\kern0.17em \mathrm{value}=\mathrm{total}\%\mathrm{species}\kern0.17em \mathrm{frequency}+\mathrm{total}\%\mathrm{species}\kern0.17em \mathrm{abundance}. $$

Mean basal area, mean percentage cover, Shannon-Weiner diversity index, and mean species richness were calculated for each distance class at each site. Species richness was calculated as the total number of species at each distance class. Diversity was calculated using the Shannon diversity index as:

$$ {H}^{\hbox{'}}=\sum \limits_{i=1}^S pi\;\ln pi $$

where H′ is the Shannon diversity index, S is the total number of species in the community, and p is the proportion of S made up of ith species (Shannon 1948). Basal area m²/hectare at each distance class was calculated as.

$$ \mathrm{Basal}\kern0.17em \mathrm{area}=\frac{\mathrm{Sum}\;\mathrm{of}\kern0.17em \mathrm{the}\kern0.17em \mathrm{basal}\kern0.17em \mathrm{area}\kern0.17em \mathrm{of}\kern0.17em \mathrm{each}\kern0.17em \mathrm{tree}\;}{\mathrm{Area}\kern0.17em \mathrm{of}\kern0.17em \mathrm{the}\kern0.17em \mathrm{sample}\kern0.17em \mathrm{plot}\kern0.34em \mathrm{in}\kern0.17em \mathrm{hectares}} $$

Mean percentage cover was also determined for five common species at each site. Data were tested for normality using Kolmogorov-Smirnov while homogeneity of variance was tested using the Levene test. After all, the assumptions of normality and homogeneity of variance were met (p > 0.05). One-way ANOVA and Tukey post hoc test were used to test for statistically significant differences between these vegetation parameters among distance classes (0–10 m, 10–20 m, 20–30 m, 30–40 m, and 40–50 m).

Generalized linear mixed model analysis was used to test for the overall impact of distance from surface water and site on plant parameters in the Okavango Delta.

Results

One-way ANOVA showed that there was no significant difference in mean basal area in Boro (df = 4, mean square = 0.225, F = 1.039, p = 0.386) and Seronga (df = 4, mean square = 0.053, F = 0.454, p = 0.769). In Jao, Tukey post hoc analysis showed that mean basal area was significantly higher at 0–10 m than at 10–20 m (mean = 0.28, p = 0.0001), 20–30 m (mean = 0.062, p = 0.001), 30–40 m (mean = 0.059, p = 0.0001), and 40–50 m (mean = 0.074, p = 0.0001). In UPH, it was higher (df = 4, mean square = 0.102, F = 1.55, p = 0.189) at 10–20 m (Fig. 2).

Fig. 2

Mean basal area variation with distance from surface water in Boro (a), Seronga (b), Jao (c), and UPH (d)

Mean percentage cover differed between the distance classes across all sites. It was significantly higher in 0–10 (df = 4, mean = 9.12, p = 0.023) and 20–30 m (df = 4, mean = 4.30) in Boro while in Jao, it was marginally significantly higher in 0–10 m (df = 4, mean = 12.50, p = 0.055) than in 30–40 m (df = 4, mean = 6.59) (Fig. 3).

Fig. 3

Mean percentage cover variation with distance from surface water in Boro (a), Seronga (b), Jao (c), and UPH (d)

Mean species richness also showed variation between distance classes in different sites. However, that variation was only significant in Boro where it was significantly higher at 0–10 m (df = 4, mean = 7) than at 20–30 m (df = 4, mean = 6, p = 0.056), 30–40 m (df = 4, mean = 5, p = 0.0001), and 40–50 m (df = 4, mean = 5, p = 0.006). Mean species richness in Boro was also significantly higher in 10–20 m (df = 4, mean = 6) than in 30–40 m (df = 4, mean = 5, p = 0.014) (Fig. 4).

Fig. 4

Mean species richness with distance from surface water in Boro (a), Seronga (b), Jao (c), and UPH (d)

Mean species diversity was significantly higher at 0–10 m (df = 4, F = 5.17, mean = 1.08, p = 0.0001) and 10–20 m (df = 4, mean = 0.97, p = 0.016) than at 30–40 m (df = 4, mean = 0.64) in Boro (p < 0.05). There was no significant difference (p > 0.05) in species diversity between distances classes in Seronga (df = 4, mean square = 0.105, F = 0.300, p = 0.876), Jao (df = 4, mean square = 0.119, F = 0.664, p = 0.620) and UPH (df = 4, mean square = 0.075, F = 0.617, p = 0.652) (Fig. 5).

Fig. 5

Mean species diversity variation with distance from surface water in Boro (a), Seronga (b), Jao (c), and UPH (d)

Riparian woodland tree species composition and dominant species changed along distance from surface water gradient (Table 2).

Table 2 Variation in composition of riparian woodland species at each distance class

In terms of generalized linear mixed model analysis, it was found that diversity and basal area were significantly (p < 0.05) influenced by both distance from surface water (df = 4, p = 0.030) and site (df = 3, p = 0.030). Plant canopy cover (p = 0.054) and species richness (p = 0.029) were significantly influenced by site only.

Discussion

There was a variation in species composition along distance from surface water gradient at different sites of Boro, Jao, Seronga, and Upper Panhandle. Plant species that were found close to surface water at 0–10 m distance class include Croton megalobotrys, Syzygium cordatum, Phoenix reclinata, Searsia tenuinervis, and Garcinia livingstonei. Those that were found far from surface water at 40–50 m distance class include Hyphaene petersiana, Senegalia nigrescens, Combretum imberbe, Vachellia tortilis, and Philenoptera violacea. The distribution of species relative to surface water could be an indication of their tolerance to different moisture regimes. It is expected that sites closer to surface water at 0–10 m will experience more moisture as compared to those that are far from surface water at 40–50 m. This therefore suggests that plant species found close to surface water at 0–10 m are tolerant of high moisture content as compared to those found at 40–50 m. Furthermore, species close to surface water at 0–10 m are expected to be exposed to shallow groundwater as compared to those far at 40–50 m. This is supported by the findings from Stromberg and Richter (1996), Shafroth et al. (2000), and Baird et al. (2005) who found that woodland plant species tolerant to wet conditions and high groundwater levels are dominant at sites closer to the river bank while those that prefer dry conditions and adapted to low groundwater level dominate sites far from the river bank. Damasceno-Junior et al. (2005) in the Pantanal, Brazil, also found that flood intolerant species occupied low flooding frequency microsites while flood tolerant species inhabited regularly flooded regions. This was in support of the findings of our study.

In the Okavango Delta, riparian plant species composition and distribution may also be influenced by the intra- and multi-decadal flood variation. The hydrology of the Okavango Delta is characterized by flooding variation which occurs within and between years (Wolski et al. 2006). Due to this variation, some years or series of years receive low floods while others experience high flooding (Wolski et al. 2006). During high and low floods, the groundwater depth becomes shallow and deep respectively (McCarthy 2006). This may have consequences for riparian plant species composition and distribution. The shallow groundwater brings the toxic salts that were initially deposited in the deep layers of the ground within reach of plant roots (McCarthy et al. 1998). Therefore, shallow groundwater may pose a danger to plant survival through salt toxicity and roots submersion which leads to anoxia. This may lead to elimination or exclusion of plants that are not adapted to these new conditions imposed by rising groundwater level. Dead individuals of Croton megalobotrys, Senegalia nigrescens, Diospyros mespiliformis, and Philenoptera violacea were observed in this study, and their death could be an indication of their inability to withstand rising groundwater depth and salinity. Conversely, during low flood, the groundwater may be too deep to be reached by plant roots resulting in water stress. Only plants that are tolerant of dry conditions through development of tap roots to reach for the deep groundwater layers and shedding of their leaves to minimize water loss may survive while those that are intolerant of dry conditions may be eliminated. This may explain the variation in riparian species composition along distance from surface water found in the Okavango Delta (Table 2).

Species richness varied significantly with distance from surface water in all the sites. This is in agreement with Lite et al. (2005) who also observed variation in species richness in the San Pedro River with increasing distance from surface water. It implies that different species establish along the groundwater depth gradients to which they are adapted along distance from surface water gradient in both the Okavango Delta. Salinity tolerance may also determine species richness along the distance from surface water gradient. McCarthy (2006) found that as the distance from surface water increases, salinity levels also increase in the Okavango Delta. This leads to woodland species tolerant of salinity and deep groundwater table colonizing areas further away from the surface water. In this study, distribution of species could be influenced by salinity gradients along the distance from surface water continuum. For instance, in Boro, species that are tolerant to saline conditions such as Hyphaene petersiana and Combretum imberbe (Ringrose et al. 2007) were found in the 40–50 m distance class which was associated with high salt levels. This is consistent with Ellery et al. (1993) who observed plant zonation along a salinity gradient in the Okavango Delta where the fringes of the islands with low salinity levels were colonized by riparian woodland species of Syzygium cordatum, Ficus sycomorus, Phoenix reclinata, Garcinia livingstonei, and Diospyros mespiliformis. The island interiors with relatively higher salinity levels than the fringes were colonized by Croton megalobotrys, Senegalia nigrescens, and Hyphaene petersiana with the center of the islands with overall high salt levels dominated by non-woody species of Sporobolus spicatus (Vahl) Kunth. This zonation suggests that each distance class from surface water, different woody species have different levels of salinity which they can tolerate and beyond which they may be completely excluded.

The current study has also indicated that mean basal area significantly varied with distance from surface water across different sites. It was high at 0–10 m and 40–50 m in Boro and Seronga and significantly higher at 0–10 and 10–20 m in Jao and UPH respectively. High mean basal area in Boro at sites closer to the permanent swamp and those that were at 40–50 m could be an indication that depth to groundwater at this distance from surface water in these sites was suitable for the establishment of large woody species. Examples of these species found at 0–10 m in the Boro system include Diospyros mespiliformis, Ficus sycomorus, P. violacea, and Garcinia livingstonei which have contributed to large basal area. In Seronga, species which contributed to the larger basal area at 0–10 m were Syzygium cordatum, D. mespiliformis, and G. livingstonei. These species are tolerant of shallow groundwater conditions (Ellery et al. 1993) which may explain their establishment at 0–10 m as this distance class is likely to be characterized by shallow groundwater depth since it is close to surface water.

Mean plant species diversity was significantly higher at 0–10 m and 10–20 m than at 30–40 m in Boro while there was no significant variation within other sites. High species diversity at these distance classes may imply that there was co-existence of species tolerant of high and low depth to groundwater (Huston 1979) as a result of changing flooding magnitude during both short and long periods. During high floods, species that do not prefer permanent flooding and those that are tolerant of it may co-exist. The co-existence of these two sets of species may lead to an increase in species diversity as predicted by the intermediate disturbance hypothesis. The hypothesis predicts that at intermediate disturbance levels, species diversity increases due to the co-existence of both competitive and opportunistic species (Huston 1979). However, diversity may eventually decrease if flooding in the riparian zone occurs for a duration long enough to kill the species that are intolerant of flooding. Conversely, if there is long-term drying and high depth to groundwater in the riparian zone, species that prefer wet conditions will be excluded resulting in a decrease in species diversity.

In the Boro and Seronga systems, the 0–10 m distance class was colonized by species such as P. violacea, D. mespiliformis, G. livingstonei, and F. sycomorus which prefer shallow groundwater; Ziziphus mucronata, Vachellia hebeclada, Senegalia nigrescens, and Dichrostachys cinerea which are tolerant of deep depth to groundwater; and Combretum imberbe and Hyphaene petersiana adapted to saline groundwater conditions (Ringrose et al. 2007). Therefore, the co-existence of these species with different preferences of groundwater chemistry and depth may have led to an increase in diversity at 0–10 m in Boro and Seronga. Jao had significantly high species diversity at 40–50 m while in UPH, diversity was significantly lower at this distance class. This was because of species at 40–50 m which tolerated dry conditions and resulted in high species diversity. Some of these species were Senegalia galpinii, S. nigrescens, Grewia bicolor, D. cinerea, and P. nelsii which were excluded from other distance classes probably due to unfavorable flooding and groundwater conditions. Conversely, in UPH, species diversity was significantly lower at 40–50 m distance class. This is because it was dominated by species that are mostly tolerant of deep groundwater table while those that prefer shallow groundwater were excluded. Conversely, other distance classes in UPH had species that were tolerant of both high and low groundwater tables co-existing which resulted in high diversity suggesting that they may have experienced intermediate disturbance levels from flooding. This is in agreement with Pollock et al. (1998) who also found that there was an increase in species diversity at sites that experienced intermediate levels of flooding disturbance. Generally, the consistency of these study results with those of other wetlands elsewhere suggests that functionally these ecosystems are similar in terms of the influence of hydrology on vegetation communities.

Conclusions

This study showed that riparian woodland characteristics differed significantly with distance from surface water within and between in all the sites. As the distance from surface water increases, it is expected that depth to groundwater also increases. As a result, different species establish in microsites to which they are adapted along the gradient of distance from surface water. These results suggest that plant species composition, basal area, and species richness may be used as indicators of the hydrologic status of a given site in the Okavango Delta. This will be useful in areas where the information on that is not available.